Are Jim Crow Laws Alive and Well?

A local group said residents need to speak out against local drug laws that disenfranchise residents in St. Pete.

Kurt Donley remembers being mortified after reading “The New Jim Crow” by Michelle Alexander.

Are black men being taken off the voter rolls in record numbers? Is the war on drugs the root of the problem?

The more research he did,  “the more upsetting it was,” he said.

On Monday night, at the Studio@620, Donley, who chairs the Council of Neighborhoods Associations’ public safety committee, made a brief presentation to a few dozen citizens about the book and what he sees as a major problem not only in St. Petersburg but throughout the U.S.

“Almost one out of 4 of every black persons you meet in St. Pete can’t vote,” Donley said because of the war on drugs.

According to marijuana arrest numbers provided to Donley by the St. Petersburg Police, nearly 6,300 people have been arrested in St. Pete since 2008 for a charge relating to marijuana.

Of those nearly 6,300 arrests, more than 90 percent were for possession of 20 grams or less of marijuana.

In the “The New Jim Crow,” Alexander argues that crime rates and arrest rates have always moved independently of one another.

Instead of just serving time for the crime, convicted individuals are not allowed to vote after their release. According Donley, and results from a newly released survey from StPetePolls, that is unfair.

StPetePolls asked respondents last week if they believed felons who have paid their debt to society should have the right to vote.

More than 73 percent of respondents said yes.

On Monday, public officials also spoke up in favor of coming up with solutions to disenfranchisement due to the war on drugs.

Pinellas County Sheriff candidate Scott Swope spoke of the benefits of decriminalizing marijuana.

“Prior to 1996 there were no states in the US that had any kind of marijuana decriminalization,” Swope said “Sixteen states and D.C. have it now.”

In Florida, Swope said if you have a marijuana conviction on your record you can’t get a student loan, can’t adopt a child later in life, can’t get food stamps, can’t live in pubic housing and have limited opportunities to vote.

“A truck driver arrested for possession of marijuana, now he’s out of work for year,” Swope said. “So we just took a $150 fine and turned it into a $40,000 fine. The law is replete with those kind of ancillary damages. I think the time has come for people to start talking about having a more reasonable and fiscally responsible marijuana enforcement policies.

“The County Commission just voted to raise our tax rate by 5 percent to cover expenses,” Swope added. “So now we’re going have to pay more money on our properties, at the same time we’re spending huge amounts of money on marijuana enforcement. Jailing these people, we have to feed them, clothe them. In jail you have to provide healthcare and dental care.”

Pinellas County School Board member Glen Gilzean and St. Pete City Council member Karl Nurse also voiced their concerns.

For Gilzean, increasing education and preventing people from making decisions that lead to arrests in the first place could stop the affects of the laws.

“How do we avoid this situation,” he asked. “How do we get younger people not to make those decisions, how not to make those mistakes.”

He said for people that have made mistakes and paid their time, city and county governments can play a role in getting those individuals back on his or her own feet. Gilzean said the city could hire former felons to do maintenance or lawn work.

“At the end of the day, if they can’t support themselves,” they will end up in the same place, Gilzean said.  “How do we come up with policies that make sense.”

Nurse, who represents nearly half of the poorest neighborhoods in St. Pete, said the current laws handicap those individuals from every getting ahead in life and standing on their own two feet.

The city, Nurse said, also needs to focus on the drug dealers and not marijuana possessions.

“What happens is, because you’re working on things like marijuana possession, you don’t have time to do the real stuff,” Nurse said. “I look at the arrests every week and ask, don’t we ever arrests the big dogs? And the answer is ‘no we don’t.’”

Nurse said the shift in priorities for the St. Petersburg Police Department is unlikely.

“The police department will resist this,” Nurse said. “… it is outside their comfort zone. If we are going to make a change, it’s going to require these types of seminars.

Donley said it is important for citizens to speak up in great numbers or nothing will happen.

In a release prior to the event, Donley wrote, “The purpose of the event is to start to raise awareness and bring our community together to push back at discriminatory laws, policies and attitudes that have contributed towards the mass incarceration, disenfranchisement and generational economic disparity of people of color (at a rate significantly worse than that that of South Africa during the height of Apartheid). Quietly without much fanfare we are on the verge of becoming a society that creates a permanent lower economic caste. Morals aside, seeing as that lower caste constitutes 1\4 of Saint Petersburg that poses a severe financial and social threat to all of us.”

Hall Palmer September 27, 2012 at 12:44 PM
It is not an arrest but rather a conviction that results in the loss of the voting franchise.
Malcolm Kyle September 27, 2012 at 01:25 PM
Prohibition has finally run its course: Our prisons are full, our economy is in ruins, the lives and livelihoods of tens of millions of Americans have been destroyed or severely disrupted, and what was once a shining beacon of liberty and prosperity has become a toxic, repressive, smoldering heap of hypocrisy and a gross affront to fundamental human decency. If you sincerely believe that prohibition is a dangerous and counter-productive policy then you can stop helping to enforce it. You are entitled—required even—to act according to your conscience! * It only takes one juror to prevent a guilty verdict. * You are not lawfully required to disclose your voting intention before taking your seat on a jury. * You are also not required to give a reason to the other jurors on your position when voting. Simply state that you find the accused not guilty! * Jurors must understand that it is their opinion, their vote. If the Judge and the other jurors disapprove, too bad. There is no punishment for having a dissenting opinion. “It is not only [the juror's] right, but his duty … to find the verdict according to his own best understanding, judgment, and conscience, though in direct opposition to the direction of the court.” —John Adams We must create what we can no longer afford to wait for: PLEASE VOTE TO ACQUIT!
Red September 27, 2012 at 01:32 PM
Yeah Kurtin, seems like if their ideas are no good the plan is to cheat. No honor, no ideas, no ethics.
sparky September 27, 2012 at 04:29 PM
Wait wait don't tell me that if you are convicted of a crime that the cause and effect relationship is only to take your vote away. Drug use is a crime- right or wrong. Some guy wiped out on a couch that has to get up and go to the polls is more likley to vote Democratic-why exactly. Its more likely that they don't have a clue that it is voting day, much less who is running. Maybe the Democrats want to be able to trade a doobie for a vote- Ya think! Don't like the law change it, but don't say its there to keep a group from voting. I think that in America we have too many people in jail due to mandatory sentencing and that is a big problem...lets solve that one and we will see the number of minorities in jails go down along with the number of whites.
cherie serjeant September 27, 2012 at 05:37 PM
The war on drugs costs this country billions of dollars and a lot of lost lives.The people don't reap the benefits of everything that is confiscated and end up paying a lot in raised taxes If a person does the time for the crime.they definitely should be given back their rights. I thought that was the original law? Our prisons and jails are overflowing with people committing non violent crimes! When is it going to end!!!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »