.
Feedback

Pier Lawsuit Mediation Ends in Impasse

No agreement on ballot language was reached. It will now be up to the judge to decide if a vote on the future of the St. Petersburg Pier happens.

Monday's pier lawsuit mediation between the City of St. Petersburg and attorney Kathleen Ford ended with an impasse, according to VoteOnThePier.com chairman Tom Lambdon. 

Any possible citizens' vote on the future of the St. Petersburg Pier will now be in the hands of Circuit Judge Jack Day. 

"As the leader of this two and a half year long fight with city leaders to afford city voters the opportunity to have the final say regarding the fate of the iconic centerpiece structure of the downtown waterfront park system, I believe it is most important at this juncture that we maintain our faith and trust in the judicial system to appropriately decide the merits of the case," Lambdon told Patch.

"And additionally hopeful (the court) considers that to date, more than 23,000 registered city voters have signed our petition asking the city to place the Pier’s final fate and future appropriately in their hands via a citywide referendum," Lambdon added.

Ford filed the lawsuit in August 2012 on to hold a citywide vote on the future of the St. Petersburg Pier after a vote was denied by city council. 

In December, Judge Amy Williams ordered the city and Ford to go into mediation. The first mediation meeting was held Jan. 18 and was continued after no agreement was made. 

The St. Petersburg Pier is still on track to close May 31. 

Lambdon said that while he opposes the "Lens," which is the Michael Maltzan pier design slated to replace the existing pier, it is important to note that the Stop the Lens group petition does not stop the pier from closing. It does not stop the pier from being demolished. 

"The public needs to be made aware that the Stop The Lens petition does not in any way stop the demolition of the entire existing Pier," Lambdon said. "It also does not save a single of the more than 400 full and part-time jobs that will be lost forever as a result of the 30 businesses that will be closed forever in May 2013."

Demolition for the Pier is slated to begin in August.  

Peter J Dunlay January 29, 2013 at 06:24 pm
Occupy The Pier On Memorial Day!
Patriot January 29, 2013 at 07:13 pm
What a waste of time! A simple YES or NO on the EYE will work just fine!
Lauren Berns January 29, 2013 at 07:38 pm
The fact that the "Stop the Lens" petition does not preserve the Pier is its greatest strength.
sparky January 29, 2013 at 08:44 pm
The arrogance of our mayor in not having his legal staff draft a proper ballot item for back during the November election and then not being a present and active part of the mediation effort. I don't care if Foster is the first person to qualify to run for the next election- he is qualified by a Four year Failure to help this city not to be re-elected. Didn't he look great in an empty Sweetbay Parking Lot with microphones talking to no one. Didn't he look like an overweight buffon with the Circ de Sole tightrope walker. Wasting our money on the Lens doesn't mean we will waste our vote on Foster.
sparky January 29, 2013 at 08:45 pm
What? You don't pay property taxes do you?
portafish January 29, 2013 at 09:57 pm
Since we pay the taxes, I think we should be able to vote on the fate of the pier. I am totally against the Lens. It will not attract locals and visitors to just walk around and do nothing. I have been enjoying the pier tremendously and the beautiful views from it. I have watched numerous people on the pier either sightseeing, fishing, souvenir shopping, or eating and enjoying the music and entertainment.
Rider January 29, 2013 at 10:43 pm
The City (which is not representative of the citizens on this issue) must not have done a good job in getting the case dismissed, which has been their strategy all along. Bravo to Kathleen Ford for putting them on edge and taking it this far. Thanks for all your hard work, Ms. Ford.
Wanda January 30, 2013 at 12:46 am
I just wonder if the plan with the Lens will replace the 400 jobs lost. Also what will be enticing for the residents and tourists to visit the pier and take their out of town guests? Honestly, I like the Pier as it is, however change is inevitable, so what plans will be as inviting as what we have now? All we hear is tear down, tear down, what we want is a projected forecast to replace jobs and add some. What will be free about it, is an interesting question.
Johann January 30, 2013 at 03:12 am
Rider, the case is not dismissed. Mediation failed. Now the parties continue with litigation, which could last weeks, months...years even. All this, for a City Attorney that stated in open court that the City was "ready, willing, able & eager" to hold a referendum on the fate of the existing Pier. They want the Pier demolished before election day. It's not a lens, it's a monument to Foster & Curran, who, ironicly hate each other. Strange bedfellows....
Dharma January 30, 2013 at 12:46 pm
ok let me help with the languag issue:
1. build a new pier 2. rebuild the exisiting peir. (that seems easy enough to understand the say we can do this....) by the way if the judge cannot see that this is something the people do not want to happen, via petetions and show of no hands then i am not sure what one can see.
Nicolas Weathersbee January 30, 2013 at 01:39 pm
That is exactly what the original VOTP petition said:
YES- refurbish the existing pier, or NO- do not refurbish existing pier. But the city confused the issue intentionally, it's one of their tools. Obfuscation, lying by omission, slight of hand, back room deals, outright lies. It's how they roll!
JDMcC January 30, 2013 at 01:56 pm
Everyone I've ever spoken with who's ever come here for the first time from out of town and gone to the Pier has, in each and every case, stated openly that by the time they get down to the end of the pier and enter the Inverted Pyramid (which looks at least somewhat interesting on the outside), they end up completely disappointed with what they find in and around the structure. The common refrain seems to be, "This is it?" Literally every single person I've ever asked about this says virtually the same thing.
The Pier is going to be demolished. Good. It's about time. It's certainly seen better days, and it offers nothing but disappointment to many tourists who are curious enough to venture up and into it.
Rider January 30, 2013 at 02:33 pm
JDMcM.....we have the exact opposite reaction from our guests going to the pier for the first time. They LOVE the 5th floor veranda open to the public, affording a magnificent view found nowhere else in St Pete.....LOVE the Columbia restaurant, LOVE the fun of Cha Cha Coconuts........LOVE riding bikes around the building in the morning and the events on this pier that attract thousands of people. They LOVED the tall ship Bounty when it was moored there. Some of our guests have been wheelchair bound (and are not seniors) and the Lens holds nothing for them, at all, and y'all are dreaming when you think that the shuttle for the handicapped will be served by the shuttle......no way at all....
Babak January 30, 2013 at 03:13 pm
This is great news, one step closer to seeing that eye sore on the water torn down. I really do hope the Stop the Lens guys get us something better than the current incarnation of the Lens. Whatever design ends up being the new pier though, it will undoubtedly be better than what we have today.
Les B. January 30, 2013 at 03:42 pm
JDMcM.....I am one of those guests from Toronto. We always make a couple of special trips to the Pier yearly from the Villa we stay in ....in Orlando. We enjoy the sights, food, shopping & in general we love conversing with many people who work inside the Pier. We love watching the people fishing from the Pier & the pelicans waiting for a handout. Everyone who we spoke with always had a ready smile & a tale or two to tell.
Dharma January 30, 2013 at 04:15 pm
good idea..
Dharma January 30, 2013 at 04:19 pm
u think what we have now is an eye sore? the lens is beyond that. its ugly, to big, and oh so white... as we seem to think we all are. imagine that in 2013. now dont get me wrong i am not in love with the colors of the pier now. if u want to do comething, change the colors to white. if u want to make a difference save taxes... and be happy you did that for yourselves and the city for its citizens..
Nicolas Weathersbee February 1, 2013 at 06:36 pm
Babak, 7 months ago St.Pete Polls showed that 68% of the people surveyed want to refurbish The Pier.
Robert Thompson March 7, 2013 at 06:48 pm
The French hated the Eiffel Tower. Now the most Famous landmark on the planet.....
Rich Nevelezer April 5, 2013 at 05:41 pm
As a visitor every year, it will be a big disappointment for my wife and I who visit the pier and buy a piece of crystal and to take a nice walk on your beautiful pier. We have been coming here for the past 6 years and we will miss it.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from St. Pete Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Jerry Kendall April 2, 2013 at 11:59 pm
I love Kahwa coffee and the nice folks that own and run it. They have been great citizens of St.Read More Pete. If you have not tried it, you should do so.